• A hand placing an individually wrapped oversized bakery cookie into a Build Your Box gift box from Mrs Davids Creations.
  • Oversized bakery cookies arranged inside a Build Your Box cookie gift box with individually wrapped flavors.
1 2

Customer Favorites 6-Pack

Customer Favorites 6-Pack

$32.00 USD
$32.00 USD
Sale Sold out

A little bit of this, a little bit of that.
In this box, you can have it all.

Can’t decide on just one favorite? We took the guesswork out of ordering and curated our most popular, customer-loved gourmet cookies into one box.

Every cookie is mixed in small batches and portioned thick (~150g / 5.3 oz) using European-style butter, premium chocolates, and real ingredients for an ultra-soft center and golden edge.

What’s inside your Customer Favorites 6-Pack

  • 2 Chocolate Indulgence: Loaded with rich dark chocolate chunks and finished with flaky sea salt.
  • 1 Creamy Bliss: Buttery and ultra-soft, with rich vanilla and cream cheese flavor.
  • 1 Golden Spice: A cozy blend of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and allspice in a thick, soft cookie.
  • 1 Celebration: Sweet vanilla and dye-free rainbow sprinkles in every colorful bite.
  • 1 Baker’s Seasonal Feature — Apple Harvest: Apple cider, freeze-dried apples, warm cinnamon, and creamy white chocolate.

Fulfillment & Freshness

  • Quantity: 6 oversized gourmet cookies (~2 lbs total).
  • Local Pickup (South Hills): Select your pickup window at checkout.
  • Nationwide Shipping: Baked fresh and shipped weekly on Tuesdays.

Pro-tip: Enjoy fresh out of the box, or warm in the oven at 350°F for 3–4 minutes for that fresh-baked, melty center.

Pickup + Shipping

Local pickup: Choose an available pickup date and time at checkout.

Shipping: Orders ship on Tuesdays. Order by Sunday for the upcoming Tuesday shipping day.

Cookies are individually heat-sealed for shipping and carefully packaged to help maintain freshness in transit.

Storage + Enjoying Your Cookie

For the best experience, enjoy within 5 days. Keeping it longer? Freeze your cookie for later.

When you're ready for that soft, bakery-style bite again, thaw your cookie and warm it in the microwave for about 20 seconds.

Pro tip: That little bit of warmth brings the soft center and melty goodness right back.

Ingredients + Allergens

Allergen Information: Our cookies are baked in a kitchen that uses wheat, eggs, milk, soy, and nuts. While some flavors do not contain nuts as an ingredient, cross-contact may occur.

View full details